Yellowtail

Nestled in the heart of Rutherford, NJ, Yellowtail stands out as a premier destination for lovers of authentic Japanese and Asian cuisine. This vibrant sushi restaurant and takeaway spot offers a carefully curated menu that showcases the freshest ingredients and skillfully crafted dishes, making it a must-visit for anyone craving impeccable sushi and Japanese flavors.

From the moment you step inside Yellowtail, you’re greeted by a warm, inviting atmosphere that blends casual elegance with a lively, friendly vibe. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a takeaway, every experience here feels personal and attentive, amplified by the truly exceptional service from staff like Ellie and Beth who consistently bring a welcoming and thoughtful touch.

The menu is a treasure trove of Japanese classics alongside creative rolls and enticing entrees. Popular offerings like the California Roll and Shrimp Tempura Roll boast a perfect balance of fresh seafood and crisp textures, delivering that satisfying crunch and delicate flavor that sushi aficionados crave. For those seeking a bit more adventure, the Yellowtail Jalapeno and the Tuna Bluefin options provide bursts of heat and depth, while the Sushi & Sashimi for 3 platter is a lavish feast that highlights the chef’s expert selection of pristine seafood.

But Yellowtail's appeal extends beyond sushi. Dishes like the Beef Negimaki and Chicken Katsu offer hearty, flavorful bites infused with authentic Asian seasonings. The Bimbimbap and Curry Rice cater beautifully to those yearning for a comforting bowl, rich with vibrant textures and robust umami flavors. Don't overlook the subtle delights like the crisp Seaweed Salad or warm, soothing Miso Soup, which perfectly complement the main courses.

Customer testimonials echo the consistent quality and passion behind each dish. Genesis Veras, a long-time patron, praises Yellowtail as “by far the best sushi spot I have been to in the area,” highlighting both the freshness of the food and the standout service. Jocelyn Lee applauds the restaurant for its reasonable pricing and generous portions, mentioning favorites such as the “sashimi deluxe” and the specialty rolls — a clear nod to the spot’s menu diversity and quality. Even those new to the scene, like Vira and Esteres Neduolc, rave about the promptness and friendliness of the staff coupled with the consistently fresh food, ensuring each visit leaves a lasting impression.

For dessert lovers, Yellowtail offers unique ice cream flavors including green tea and red bean, adding an authentic Japanese twist to the finish of your meal. This attention to detail and culinary authenticity is what transforms a simple dinner into a memorable occasion.

If you find yourself in Rutherford craving expertly crafted sushi or authentic Japanese comfort dishes served in a friendly, attentive setting, Yellowtail is an unequivocal choice. Freshness, flavor, and flawless service come together here to create an experience that keeps locals—and newcomers alike—coming back for more.